TITLE: Dear Deirdre – Your HR Agony Aunt | Edition 7: Stealing Petty Cash
What should I do about an employee who was caught stealing at work? Stealing petty cash can be classified as theft and is considered gross misconduct which can lead to a dismissal from the employer. This month’s Dear Deirdre – HR Agony Aunt from BeyondHR looks at how employers should approach a situation where an employee is stealing petty cash at work, why a discreet investigation should happen first and what could happen if the evidence proves the employee is guilty.
Dear Deirdre,
I run a small shop near the north coast, and I have recently discovered that money has been going missing from our petty cash.
I suspect that an employee may be responsible as there have been no signs of a break-in and the end-of-day cash totals are not adding up as they should. This has caused considerable concern for our small business, particularly because of the potential breach of trust and the uncertainty surrounding the situation.
I want to address the matter fairly without acting on suspicion alone, but I feel like I have no other choice.
How can I begin a formal process?
Owner – Small Shop North Coast
Dear Owner,
It is understandable to be concerned over discrepancies in petty cash especially if an employee is responsible. However, this issue should be addressed promptly to establish the facts, avoid unfounded accusations and prevent any further incidents.
Begin An Investigation
Before jumping to any conclusions and making false accusations, start by investigating the problem further with the employee to check there is not a manual error, or checking relevant evidence such as CCTV footage as well as any witness statements and account records that would back up the allegation. As a precautionary measure, you may want to consider suspending them on full pay during this time until the disciplinary takes place.
Disciplinary Hearing
If there is strong evidence from the investigation that indicates an employee is guilty, a disciplinary meeting should be held to discuss the misconduct formally. This meeting should be between the employer and employee to each state their case and respond to any evidence that is provided, keeping a written record of all that is discussed in case it’s needed later in the procedure. Once the relevant information has been addressed and a decision on next steps has been made, the employee should receive the outcome to this process in writing as well. As theft is considered gross misconduct, the decision that may be come to is a summary dismissal.
Company Policy
During the disciplinary meeting, the employee should have been given the opportunity to clear up what happened surrounding the misconduct. If it is discovered that the employee had unintentionally stolen petty cash as they only started employment recently and may have had a lack of training or incorrectly misplaced the petty cash, this may be mitigation to reduce the level of warning.
Additionally, the employee should be made aware of the company’s policies on the handling of cash in the employee handbook as well as the disciplinary procedure that can follow as a result.
Formal Warning
The employee may be given a formal warning to avoid a similar situation from happening again if the case does not go through as gross misconduct, and the employer may request that the employee undertakes staff training if it was a competence issue. The employer should warn that if their attitude or performance does not improve, the employee may be demoted or even dismissed.
Regards,
Deirdre
Need HR Support?
Stealing petty cash should be quickly stopped to ensure that there is no further damage made to the business and to other employees.
Noticeable payment or account issues should be dealt with as soon as possible through an immediate investigation then a disciplinary, if proven necessary. There should be clear company policies and procedures in place to protect the employer if an employee has stolen from the business and relevant staff training should be given in advance to avoid such eventualities.
For more information on handling an employee stealing petty cash in the workplace and a disciplinary investigation, download our free guide here.
Have a workplace question for Deirdre? Submit it anonymously for the chance to be featured in a future edition of Dear Deirdre. For confidential advice tailored to your business, contact the BeyondHR team on 028 2564 4110.








0 Comments